Sign up for free newsletter


Numbers and magnifying glass

Good fund stewardship practices produce better results, says Morningstar

Asset managers with good fund stewardship practices have produced better outcomes for investors, according to research from Morningstar.

Morningstar analysts examined stewardship practices alongside the firms' success ratios, which Morningstar defines as the percentage of a firm's funds that have survived and outperformed the median fund in a respective category, considering the funds' total returns as well as risk-adjusted returns.
Specifically, the analysts evaluated four Morningstar firm-level data points that measure stewardship – average manager tenure, manager retention rates, manager ownership of fund shares, and Morningstar fee level – which Morningstar calculates for more than 750 US asset managers. Morningstar then assessed whether firms with positive stewardship data had stronger success ratios. The analysts also evaluated this data among the 179 firms that receive Morningstar's qualitative stewardship ratings.
Overall, Morningstar found that higher manager retention and tenure, higher manager ownership in funds, and lower fees coincide with more positive Morningstar stewardship ratings and superior success ratios.
"We undertook this study to determine whether our belief that firms with good stewardship practices provide better investor outcomes was evident, and the results strongly support that conclusion," says Bridget Hughes, Morningstar's associate director of fund research and lead author of the study. "Our proprietary, firm-level data points measure whether asset managers are aligning their interests with their funds' shareholders, in terms of manager tenure and retention, manager ownership in funds, and fees. In turn, these data points inform our assessment of firm stewardship, expressed through our stewardship grades and the parent component of our analyst ratings for the funds and fund companies we cover."
As of 31 January 2014, analysts assigned four "A" Morningstar Stewardship Grades, six "B" grades, and 10 "C" grades to the largest US fund firms, which represent more than two-thirds of the industry's total US mutual fund assets. The four firms that earn an "A" are American Funds, Dodge & Cox, T Rowe Price, and Vanguard.
Fund firms with average manager tenure of more than 15 years exhibit higher success ratios, or the percentage of a firm's funds that have survived and outperformed the median fund in a respective category, than fund firms with average manager tenures of zero to three years.
Fund firms with a 95 to 100 per cent five-year manager retention rate have achieved the strongest average success ratios. Morningstar's manager retention rate measures what percentage of a firm's portfolio managers have stayed at the company for a specific period of time.
Firms with 80 to 100 per cent of their fund assets where at least one manager has more than USD1m invested report the best success ratios, on average. Firms with less than 20 per cent of their fund assets where at least one manager has more than USD1m invested tend to have the worst success ratios.
Firms with lower average fee levels report better success ratios over three-, five-, and 10-year periods.
A correlation matrix, which measures the existence of two characteristics together but doesn't necessarily indicate causation, suggests that the data points featured in the study are largely independent measures of stewardship and together help identify strong caretakers of capital.

1 week 4 days from now - New York
1 week 6 days from now - New York
9 weeks 5 days from now - New York
11 weeks 3 days from now - Monte Carlo
Eden Rock Capital Management
Wed, 15/06/2016 - 17:30
UBS Global Asset Management
Fri, 06/05/2016 - 14:19
RFA (Richard Fleischman & Associates)
Tue, 05/04/2016 - 14:25
other gfm publications